I’m posting this article, from Worship Leader Magazine, to generate some discussion from the Harvest worship volunteers –  feel free to comment.

I’m moved by the last couple of sentences as Kidd writes, “The difference in our religions is a mystery you more experience in worship than figure out in your head. We do worship Jesus because it’s the Son’s divinity that gives him the right to forgive. And we worship alongside Jesus because the Son has become our brother and made his Father ours.”

What do you think?




By Reggie Kidd

Worship Leader Magazine, September 2011

AHMED: Our religions are the same. You call him Elohim, and I call him Allah. Both words mean the same thing: “God.” We both believe Jesus is God’s Son and was born of a virgin. We both believe he will come again at the end of time.

ME: But do you worship Jesus, Ahmed?

AHMED: Of course not, that would be blasphemy! The Son is not the same as Allah.

ME: Then, no, friend, our religions are not the same.


In my conversation with Ahmed, I realized how easy Christianity’s “sell” would be if we could just accept his logic that if there is one and only one God, then Father, Son, and Holy Spirit can’t each be God.

The Church of the first half-millennium bequeathed to us a fabulous gift: their stubborn refusal to surrender the lessons they had learned from Scripture and in worship to other voices. One voice said: “Just put Jesus a little below the Father and as high above us as we wish. Make Jesus a fellow creature with us, one through whom we worship, but not one to whom we offer worship.”

Its opposite said: “Elevate Jesus so far above us that he becomes just a ‘face’ that God condescends to use to communicate with us without dragging him down to the material.”

Make Jesus less than fully divine or less than fully human. Either way, he becomes more plausible, more understandable … more, well … marketable.

If early Christians had accepted either of these options-the one at the hands of Arians, the other at the hands of Gnostics-the church could have known early, easy success. As it is, though, Scripture told our spiritual forebears that “the Word became flesh.” Worship taught them both sides of the equation: the Word became flesh, and the Word became flesh.


Scripture teaches truths that worship shapes into habits of the heart. One is that only God can save. Even Jesus’ enemies recognized that statements like “Your sins are forgiven” were claims to deity. John the Baptist declared Jesus to be “the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world” On 1:29). Instinctively, the Church has translated that statement into prayer: “Lamb of God, you take away the sin of the world, have mercy on us.”

Early Christians cultivated the habit of praying to Jesus: You are seated at the right hand of the Father. Receive our prayer. You alone are the Holy One, you alone are the Lord, you alone are the Most High, Jesus Christ, with the Holy Spirit, in the glory of God the Father. Amen.

Thus they insulated themselves from claims that the Word is less than fully divine.

Most of us live in a cultural environment in which Jesus is a great man, perhaps larger than life, maybe even semi-divine. But not God. However, if he is not God, then he doesn’t really save. We’re left to try to save ourselves, however we define salvation. The greatest thing we can offer our secularist friends, our Muslim friends, our Jehovah’s Witness friends, is to worship not some generic “Lord,” but the distinctly Trinitarian God. This is the God who redeems-Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

To some people, it seemed (and still seems) unworthy of God to think of him actually becoming human. So they sought (and seek) to protect the purity of God by having a fully divine Christ, but one who sort of passed through Mary rather than took substance from her. Jesus’ humanity disappears or at least withers. Unfortunately, so does ours.

Most Christians, however, understand that since our problem-sin-includes body, mind, soul, and spirit, so does our solution. To heal and rescue us, Jesus had to become one of us. The incarnation was not a “drive by” salvation. Jesus has come, and is coming, in the flesh (compare 1 John 2:26 & 2 John 7). Thus we look for new bodies, not angels’ wings.


That’s why “matter matters” in worship. Baptismal waters are simultaneously “our tomb” (the death of the “old man”) and “our mother” (the birth of the “new man”), as Cyril, Jerusalem’s 4th century bishop put it. Anointing with oil at baptism (Greek: chrisma) makes us little “Christs.” In Communion “we become one body and blood with Christ–Christ bearers–thus, the kiss of peace at Communion is not just any old greeting, but an expression of “a union of souls.”

Here’s what I wish I had thought to say to Ahmed: The difference in our religions is a mystery you more experience in worship than figure out in your head. We do worship Jesus because it’s the Son’s divinity that gives him the right to forgive. And we worship alongside Jesus because the Son has become our brother and made his Father ours.


Reggie Kidd


Wrote the book “With One Voice” and teaches at Reformed Theological Seminary.




5 thoughts on “Mystery Matters, by Kidd

  1. Interesting I just saw a post on one of my nieces fb page from one of her relatives..that said “Praise Allah” I wondered who/what that was. I’m sad to know they than do not believe that Jesus is God..Because we know that he indeed is God.
    As His article says “Only God can Save”.
    I also enjoyed the idea of becoming one body and blood with Christ in Communion..”a union of souls” with our family of believers at Harvest! That is probably why I love this church family so much:)


  2. I just read the article by Reggie Kidd, “Mystery Matters.” The issue of Jesus as God has always been pretty simple in my mind. If Jesus is not God, if He is anything less than God, such as a prophet or a divine person, then he is also a liar. Since a prophet of God or a divine being could never be a liar (that would take away that position of holiness), then that leaves one option…God. He cannot be anything other than what He says, or else he is nothing. Would you follow a great guy who happens to lie about the most important thing? No! Truth cannot lie. Simple.

  3. Good article. I believe we need to boldly stand up for our unique faith of worshiping our triune God. Christ and His position in the Godhead separates us from other religions. We need to stop apologizing for our faith and boldly proclaim the gospel of Christ.

  4. the author writes in the last sentence…”And we worship alongside Jesus because the Son has become our brother and made his Father ours.” Here’s some scripture that comes to mind, the ‘he’ in this passage refers to Jesus —

    …For he who sanctifies and those who are sanctified all have one source. That is why he is not ashamed to call them brothers, saying, “I will tell of your name to my brothers; in the midst of the congregation I will sing your praise.”
    (Hebrews 2:11-12 ESV)

    remember this next time you’re mixing, operating the computer or musically leading worship and be encouraged!

  5. Well-thought-out final comment by Reggie! To tie in with Tracy’s comment, if Jesus is not God, then all of Christianity is false and we are wasting our time. So proclaim Jesus boldly (yes, Brad!) and praise and honor Him with everything you think, do, and say.

    Kathy, what an absolutely wonderful prayer opportunity for you and for your niece! And what a conversation opportunity for you with your niece.

    In the beginning, the Word was with God and the Word was God!

Leave a Reply to Tom Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *